GLOBAL. 3.0

FREE. FAIR. GLOBAL.

Who Gets to Speak for the World? Choosing the Next UN Secretary-General

As the race to succeed António Guterres changes, the deeper question is what kind of leadership governments will allow the United Nations to exercise.

Austin Mitchell Wallace

The United Nations headquarters complex across the East River, November 18, 2024.
The United Nations headquarters complex across the East River, November 18, 2024. Archival institutional context; not the Secretary-General selection process or any candidate. © Superbass / CC-BY-SA-4.0 (via Wikimedia Commons). Image source · CC BY-SA 4.0. Original photographic file; display crop may vary.

As the race to succeed António Guterres changes, the deeper question is what kind of leadership governments will allow the United Nations to exercise.

The United Nations is choosing the person who will be asked to speak when governments stop listening to one another. That sounds like an impossible job. Some days, it probably is.

António Guterres’s second term ends on 31 December 2026. The appointment of his successor will therefore help define how the organization enters 2027, and how it responds to the distance between its founding promises and the political realities of the present. The end date was established when the General Assembly reappointed Guterres in 2021.

There will be a new name. Whether there will be renewed authority depends on much more than the person selected.

The Power Behind the Appointment

The procedure is straightforward on paper. Under Article 97 of the UN Charter, the General Assembly appoints the Secretary-General on the recommendation of the Security Council. The Council’s five permanent members can block a candidate, giving China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States decisive influence over the choice. The UN’s explanation of the process makes that imbalance clear.

This creates a difficult bargain. Candidates must be acceptable to governments whose interests can collide, then demonstrate enough independence to challenge those same governments once in office.

The Charter gives that independence a foundation. Article 100 requires the Secretary-General and staff to avoid taking instructions from governments. Article 99 allows the Secretary-General to bring threats to international peace and security before the Council. These are powers and obligations of the office, although they cannot compel agreement among states.

That distinction matters. A capable Secretary-General can open a channel for negotiation, focus attention on suffering and insist that principles apply consistently. But personal courage cannot substitute for governments willing to act. The appointment tells us something about the candidates. It also tells us what the powerful are prepared to tolerate.

A Field That Has Already Changed

The public record needs careful reading. As of 28 September, the nominations recorded by the UN, read alongside subsequent withdrawal notices, identify seven remaining candidates: Ivonne A-Baki, María Fernanda Espinosa Garcés, Rafael Mariano Grossi, Rebeca Grynspan Mayufis, Olara Otunnu, Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett and Macky Sall. The official selection register provides their nomination documents and campaign materials.

Michelle Bachelet’s candidacy was withdrawn effective 21 September, after Brazil and Mexico notified the presidents of the Assembly and Council. That joint letter supersedes older accounts that still place her in the race. Virginia Gamba’s nomination had already been withdrawn in March.

The field expanded well beyond the four candidates who appeared in April’s first dialogues. The Assembly’s account records further dialogues in June and August, a July town hall and Security Council straw polls in July and August. These developments are documented in its review of the selection process.

Those public appearances give people outside diplomatic missions a way to examine the contenders. They do not, by themselves, tell us who can secure the Council’s recommendation. A strong performance in public and a viable path through great-power politics are different tests.

Who the Institution Represents

There is also a question the UN has carried for its entire history. Its nine Secretaries-General have all been men, as the organization’s record of previous officeholders shows.

Selecting a woman would change that history. It would matter to an institution that asks governments to take equality seriously. Representation influences whose experience enters the room, which barriers are recognized and who can imagine themselves exercising authority.

It should also sharpen scrutiny. Every candidate should face substantive questions about judgment, management, human rights and the willingness to defend the Charter when doing so becomes inconvenient. Equality cannot mean demanding perfection from women while accepting political compromise as evidence of experience in men.

Geography matters too. Many countries want leadership that understands how international decisions are experienced outside the most powerful capitals. But the UN confirms there is no official regional rotation rule. Claims that the office automatically belongs to a particular region should be treated as political arguments, not established procedure.

The Job After the Vote

The next Secretary-General will inherit an institution already trying to reorganize itself. In her 3 September assessment of the UN80 initiative, outgoing Assembly President Annalena Baerbock described budget and staffing changes, efforts to review mandates and unfinished debates about overlapping structures. She also stressed that further reform requires the participation of member states. This is work already under way, with difficult choices still ahead.

For the candidates, that makes general promises of efficiency insufficient. They should explain how they would distinguish waste from capacity that people depend on. Which functions need clearer responsibility? Which decisions can the Secretariat make, and which require governments to change their demands or provide resources?

Diplomacy deserves equally concrete answers. When should a Secretary-General speak publicly, and when might private engagement achieve more? How would they preserve access to a government while challenging its conduct? What would they do when silence itself damages trust?

There is no formula that resolves every case. The useful test is whether candidates can explain their judgment and accept accountability for the consequences.

Governments face a test of their own. They cannot credibly ask for stronger international cooperation while treating an independent Secretary-General as a problem to be managed. Nor can they assign responsibilities indefinitely without confronting what delivery requires.

The world will not be repaired by one appointment. But the choice can still matter deeply. It can put someone in office who understands that trust grows through decisions people can see and assess: a negotiation sustained, a warning delivered, a promise matched with resources.

The next Secretary-General will need room to exercise that judgment. The governments making the choice will have to decide whether they are willing to provide it.

Sources