FREE. FAIR. GLOBAL.
COP17 negotiators advance marine guidance as Russia opposes high-seas cooperation text
COP17’s Working Group II advanced draft marine guidance, while Russia opposed proposed cooperation with the high seas treaty and delegates left inclusion and forest provisions unresolved.
Reporting by Katherine Knisely; edited by GLOBAL.

Reporting cutoff: October 27, 2026 evening session in Yerevan
Edited by GLOBAL. from Katherine Knisely’s submitted article and meeting notes, checked against the UN-hosted automated transcript. That transcript is not an official UN record. Delegation positions are paraphrased and attributed. This report covers draft negotiations through the October 27 evening session, not final COP17 adoption.
Negotiators at the UN biodiversity conference in Yerevan agreed Tuesday evening, October 27, on draft wording for guidance on peer reviewing ecologically or biologically significant marine areas. But Russia’s opposition left a proposed expert advisory group’s links to the high seas treaty unresolved.
In Working Group II’s ninth meeting, delegates settled the title of Annex I of the marine and coastal biodiversity text, CRP.4, as voluntary guidance for peer review of descriptions of ecologically or biologically significant marine areas, known as EBSAs. Russia, which had pressed for reference elements for good practice, accepted Canada’s compromise of guidance on condition that it covers only the Convention’s own EBSA process. These were working-group agreements on draft wording, not final adoption by COP17.
Chile, Iceland, the EU, and Colombia accepted deletion of a reference to other relevant, compatible, and complementary scientific criteria from the title, though that wording remained bracketed in paragraph 4.
The title compromise also reopened discussion of text previously agreed in contact groups. Russia argued that the new title affected the annex as a whole. Delegates accepted the Chair’s shortened paragraph 8, stating that the guidance does not change the modalities adopted in Decision 16/16.
A divide formed over Annex II, the proposed terms of reference for an informal advisory group. UK wording on cooperation with other bodies, including the BBNJ Agreement, drew support from the EU, Iceland, Norway, Chile, Panama, Peru, Jamaica, the Philippines, the Cook Islands, and Tuvalu. The high seas agreement entered into force on January 17, 2026.
Russia would accept only the group’s first proposed function and rejected the formulations for functions (b) and (c), including the alternatives. With that objection unresolved, the Chair left the disputed wording in brackets.
Delegates cleared the group’s membership wording in paragraph 3 by referring to the nomination and selection guidance for expert groups in the consolidated working procedures of the Convention’s scientific advisory body, SBSTTA. A separate sentence explicitly naming indigenous peoples and local communities, women’s and youth groups, and other stakeholders was deleted. The Chair said indigenous peoples and local communities were covered by the existing procedures, while acknowledging that the procedures needed updating to address women and youth.
The debate then turned to paragraph 5, on inviting outside experts. Tuvalu, Chile, Panama, the UK, Canada, Australia, Norway, and the Cook Islands, speaking for 14 Pacific small island states, supported explicit inclusion of indigenous peoples and local communities, women, and youth. Russia would accept a reference to experts from indigenous peoples and local communities but argued that women and young scientists were already covered and questioned why business was not named. The paragraph remained bracketed. The CBD Women’s Caucus and the Global Youth Biodiversity Network urged parties to retain the explicit references.
Earlier in the meeting, delegates cleared one of six bracketed paragraphs in the forest text. Annex paragraph 20, on biodiversity-friendly practices, was agreed after the EU withdrew its request to move the reference to sustainable forest management.
Paragraph 15, on pest management, remained bracketed. Namibia, Uganda, and the EU sought deletion or a narrower scope limited to plantations. Brazil, Panama, Iran, India, and Russia supported retaining the paragraph. Tuvalu cited brown tree snakes, rats, and cane toads invading natural forests as reasons to consider pest management beyond plantations.
Paragraph 38(e), on protecting environmental human rights defenders, also remained bracketed, despite added wording linking it to national legislation and/or circumstances. Russia, India, and Iran sought deletion; India explicitly raised sovereignty concerns.
At the close of the October 27 evening session, work on CRP.4’s operative and preambular paragraphs was expected to continue the following morning, October 28. Five forest paragraphs were still pending: operative paragraphs 4 and 5 and Annex paragraphs 15, 23, and 38(e). The Chair urged further consultations to send agreed text to the Presidency. This report reflects that session’s cutoff, not subsequent negotiations or final COP17 decisions.
Sources
- UN-hosted automated transcript — COP17 Working Group II, ninth meeting, October 27, 2026; not an official record
- UN Web TV — COP17 Working Group II, ninth meeting, October 27, 2026
- Convention on Biological Diversity — Decision 16/16, October 30, 2024
- European Commission CINEA — High Seas Treaty entered into force January 17, 2026