GLOBAL. 3.0

FREE. FAIR. GLOBAL.

From London to Managua: Human Rights Lawyers Map Legal Paths to Accountability for Nicaragua

Reed Brody outlined four possible routes to accountability, from international courts and universal jurisdiction to targeted sanctions.

Reporting by Mayah Ramadan; edited by GLOBAL.

Exterior of the Peace Palace, home of the International Court of Justice in The Hague.
Archival photograph: the Peace Palace, home of the International Court of Justice in The Hague, 22 September 2013. Legal-institution context; not a photograph of the October 2026 proceedings or any defendants. Photo: Dennis G. Jarvis / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Image source · CC BY-SA 2.0. Resized and re-encoded for display under the same CC BY-SA 2.0 license; display crop may vary.

Reporting date: October 27, 2026 UN General Assembly side event

Lightly edited by GLOBAL. from Mayah Ramadan’s submitted report, with factual corrections and source verification. The report covers the October 27, 2026 UN General Assembly side event. UN-hosted automated transcripts are not official records. Statements about possible legal routes and sanctions are attributed to Reed Brody; investigative findings are not convictions.

The arrest of former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet in London in 1998 demonstrated how years of human rights documentation can eventually open the door to justice. At a United Nations General Assembly side event on October 27, 2026, human rights lawyer Reed Brody invoked that precedent while outlining four potential pathways to hold Nicaragua and senior officials accountable for alleged human rights violations.

Brody, a member of the United Nations Group of Human Rights Experts on Nicaragua (GHREN), argued that international accountability efforts must move beyond documenting abuses to pursuing concrete legal consequences. “If there's no justice today, there will be justice tomorrow, but what we document today leads to that tomorrow arriving early,” he said.

Brody said GHREN had identified 56 individuals whom it had reasonable grounds to believe were responsible for serious violations and crimes. The list includes police personnel, judges, officials in the Ministry of the Interior, mayors and prosecutors. These are investigative findings, not criminal convictions.

Brody outlined several potential avenues for accountability, starting with the International Court of Justice (ICJ). He proposed that one or more states parties could bring a case against Nicaragua under the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness over the alleged arbitrary deprivation of nationality. This route concerns the responsibility of the state, rather than criminal prosecution of individuals.

The second pathway would involve the International Criminal Court (ICC), despite Nicaragua not being a party to the Rome Statute. Brody cited the deportation of 135 people to Guatemala in 2024. Guatemala is a state party to the ICC. Pointing to the Myanmar-Bangladesh precedent, he argued that the ICC could potentially exercise jurisdiction where an element of alleged deportation occurs on the territory of a state party.

The third avenue would be universal jurisdiction. Brody cited an Argentine judge's arrest order targeting Daniel Ortega as an example of how national courts could pursue cases involving serious international crimes. He said other states could also open investigations, especially where their nationals are victims or suspects are present in their territory.

The fourth avenue is targeted sanctions. Although some of the identified individuals have already been sanctioned, Brody said half remained unsanctioned in major jurisdictions.

Brody's message was that accountability depends on preserving evidence and using available international legal mechanisms and frameworks, especially when imminent prosecution looks unlikely. For Nicaragua's victims, the challenge remains translating years of documented abuses into effective investigations, protection and justice.

Sources