FREE. FAIR. GLOBAL.
Climate finance faces a tougher test: showing what works
Independent evaluations discussed at a CGD webinar point to progress at the IMF and World Bank, alongside gaps in measuring results, tailoring support and sustaining reforms.
GLOBAL. Editorial

Webinar date: November 5, 2026
AI-assisted synthesis of the webinar recording and linked independent evaluations. This article does not claim attendance.
Independent evaluations discussed at a CGD webinar point to progress at the IMF and World Bank, alongside gaps in measuring results, tailoring support and sustaining reforms.
The IMF and World Bank have expanded their response to climate change. Demonstrating what that work achieves remains a harder task.
That challenge ran through Climate at the IMF and World Bank: What Independent Evaluations Show, a Center for Global Development webinar held on 5 November 2026 in collaboration with Evidence for Climate Action. Evaluators and policy specialists examined how the institutions are responding to countries’ needs and where their approaches need to improve.
The evidence requires careful interpretation. The IMF’s Independent Evaluation Office (IEO) has completed an early-stage assessment of the Fund’s climate work covering 2021 to mid-2025. The World Bank Group’s evaluation of its Climate Change Action Plan is still forthcoming. Its Independent Evaluation Group (IEG) instead brought lessons from existing evaluations, including work on biodiversity and the blue economy.
An expanding role for the IMF
Presenting the IMF findings, Miguel de Las Casas described strong demand for climate-related support and substantial progress in incorporating climate considerations into the Fund’s work.
The IEO’s published assessment finds that members valued the IMF’s contributions, particularly its connection of climate issues with macroeconomic and financial policy. It also finds no significant overall crowding out of other work, despite initial resource pressures and coordination problems.
The remaining weaknesses are consequential. Climate risks have been integrated unevenly into lending outside the Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF). Assessments of climate financing needs have also been insufficiently reflected in some fiscal and debt analyses.
The evaluation’s recommendations call for clearer explanations of why climate issues matter for a country’s economic stability and advice better suited to national circumstances. For low-emitting, vulnerable countries, that can mean greater attention to adaptation. It also means examining distributional effects and the trade-offs between climate investment and fiscal constraints.
Reform delivery is only part of the story
The RSF illustrates both the opportunities and the limits of the available evidence.
The evaluation’s lending chapter records strong implementation of reform measures and positive assessments from country authorities. Governments valued the financing, technical assistance and support for coordinating reforms.
However, the facility’s broader ability to attract additional finance, particularly private investment, remains unproven. Some countries reported positive effects, but separating the RSF’s contribution from other IMF programmes and wider developments was difficult.
Follow-up after arrangements ended was also uneven. Completing a reform measure does not establish whether its benefits endure. That makes continued monitoring important, especially when the risks being addressed unfold over much longer periods than a lending programme.
Looking beyond individual projects
Lauren Kelly’s presentation drew on the World Bank Group’s experience with biodiversity and the blue economy. Those evaluations offer lessons relevant to climate policy without constituting a completed assessment of the Bank’s overall climate strategy.
The biodiversity evaluation identifies weaknesses in capturing results and translating climate and nature objectives into biodiversity benefits. The blue-economy evaluation finds that sector-level achievements have not consistently supported the wider policy and institutional reforms needed for sustainable ocean development.
During the discussion, IEG Director General Sabine Bernabè highlighted the constraints of project-based incentives and narrow indicators. Julie Rozenberg, Chief Economist at the World Resources Institute, called for stronger links between project-level resilience and fiscal and debt analysis.
These questions are particularly timely. In extending its Climate Change Action Plan in June 2026, the World Bank Group announced a shift towards outcomes, retired its climate-finance percentage targets and confirmed that IEG would evaluate the plan.
For countries facing mounting climate risks, the practical test is whether international support helps sustain reforms, reduce vulnerability and make better investment decisions. Independent evaluation can make that test more credible, provided institutions act on the findings and remain clear about what the evidence cannot yet establish.