FREE. FAIR. GLOBAL.
Epistemic Racism and Democracy in Guatemala
During a November 10 lecture at Columbia University, Maya-K'iche' anthropologist Dr. Irma Alicia Velásquez Nimatuj posed a sharp question about the crisis that derailed Guatemala’s 2023 presidential election: When Indigenous authorities stepped in to save the constitutional order, did state institutions recognize them as political thinkers, or reduce them to mere demonstrators?
Gabriela Arias Torres

Reporting date: November 10, 2026
During a November 10 lecture at Columbia University, Maya-K'iche' anthropologist Dr. Irma Alicia Velásquez Nimatuj posed a sharp question about the crisis that derailed Guatemala’s 2023 presidential election: When Indigenous authorities stepped in to save the constitutional order, did state institutions recognize them as political thinkers, or reduce them to mere demonstrators?
The conversation, moderated by Tinker Visiting Professor Marisa G. Ruiz Trejo, pointed to the paradox at the heart of Guatemala’s democratic survival. Beginning on October 2, 2023, ancestral Indigenous authorities, led by the 48 Cantones of Totonicapán, the Indigenous Municipality of Sololá, and the Xinka Parliament, sustained a 106-day national strike and encampment outside the Public Prosecutor’s Office in Guatemala City. The mobilization was lifted in the early hours of January 15, 2024, after anti-corruption reformer Bernardo Arévalo was sworn into office (Ardón 2024).
Dr. Velásquez Nimatuj further explained that she understands epistemic racism to be a subtle, legalistic form of discrimination that rarely manifests as overt racial violence. Instead, it hides behind bureaucratic neutrality and professional jargon in order to rank human knowledge, thus disqualifying Indigenous peoples as producers of law, theory, and governance.
According to her, this exclusion is able to operate through three overlapping steps. First, state and academic institutions treat Indigenous peoples as objects of study rather than co-authors of knowledge. Second, the state institutionalizes myths, such as Indigenous peoples not knowing how to rule, as a way to demerit a population where about 44% identified as Maya, Xinka or Garífuna, according to a 2018 census (INE 2019, p. 10). Third, when Indigenous movements become too powerful to ignore, the state offers superficial cultural recognition while refusing to share political or territorial authority, as seen in Guatemala with the adoption of traditional dresses at official ceremonies.
Dr. Velásquez Nimatuj also commented on how, during the 2026 mobilizations, Guatemala’s ancestral authorities demonstrated a model of governance based on revocable mandates, public accountability, and complex logistics that sustained food, health, and security across protest sites for over three months. Mainstream media and state officials, however, largely framed them as mere demonstrators causing public disorder. She highlighted that the country thanked their bodies for their moral sacrifice while simultaneously ignoring the political wisdom guiding them.
This phenomenon can transcend the cultural sphere and extend into criminal law if containment fails, turning civic defense into a crime. In April 2025, prosecutors arrested former 48 Cantones leaders Luis Pacheco, Héctor Chaclán, and Basilio Puac, alongside former Sololá vice-mayor Esteban Toc Tzay, on charges of terrorism and obstruction of justice for their roles in the 2023 protests. On September 11, 2026, a judge finally dismissed the charges and ordered the cases closed after the Public Prosecutor’s own Secretariat of Indigenous Peoples acknowledged that the leaders had acted lawfully under ancestral community mandates (Amnesty International, 2026). Nearly a month later, on October 7, 2026, President Arévalo and the Attorney General’s Office held a court-ordered ceremony at the National Palace to offer a formal public apology.
For Guatemala’s fragile democracy to survive, she concluded, symbolic inclusion is no longer enough in the long run. A true democratic reform would require sharing real decision-making power over territories, establishing genuine legal pluralism that recognizes Indigenous law alongside state courts, and turning judicial dismissals into binding institutional standards. As a result, this would aid in ending the habit of relying on Indigenous service while simultaneously denying Indigenous authority.
Sources
- Amnesty International. “Guatemala: Immediate and Unconditional Release of Prisoners of Conscience Luis Pacheco and Héctor Chaclán,” May 6, 2026
- Ardón, Patricia. 2024. “How a People’s Resistance Movement Changed the Course of Guatemalan History.” Jass | Just Power
- Brown, Rich. “Timeline: Guatemala’s 2023 Election Crisis.” Americas Quarterly, April 22, 2025
- PBI Guatemala. “Political Situation in August 2026,” July 9, 2026
- Instituto Nacional de Estadística Guatemala (INE). XII Censo Nacional de Población y VII de Vivienda: Principales Resultados, Censo 2018. Ciudad de Guatemala: Instituto Nacional de Estadística Guatemala, September 2019