FREE. FAIR. GLOBAL.
Israel and the US Hinder Consensus in Third Committee Resolutions
The United States and Israel called recorded votes on five Third Committee resolutions whose sponsors had hoped they would be adopted by consensus. These included texts on social development, refugees in Africa, and a procedural step toward talks on an environmental crime treaty. Every text passed by a wide margin, with a few having three or fewer votes against. Washington cited cost, sovereignty, and its rejection of the 2030 Agenda, and Israel, time and time again, brought up bias against the Jewish state and antisemitism. Sponsors designated these demands for votes as derogatory to the committee’s habit of consensus.
Katherine Knisely

Meeting date: November 19, 2026
The UN’s official meeting coverage records 26 abstentions on the drug policy text.
The United States and Israel called recorded votes on five Third Committee resolutions whose sponsors had hoped they would be adopted by consensus. These included texts on social development, refugees in Africa, and a procedural step toward talks on an environmental crime treaty. Every text passed by a wide margin, with a few having three or fewer votes against. Washington cited cost, sovereignty, and its rejection of the 2030 Agenda, and Israel, time and time again, brought up bias against the Jewish state and antisemitism. Sponsors designated these demands for votes as derogatory to the committee’s habit of consensus.
The United States and Israel called for votes on five resolutions in the UN General Assembly’s Third Committee Thursday morning. Despite this obstruction, all five passed by wide margins, and several sponsors openly regretted the loss of consensus.
The US called a vote on a Group of 77 and China resolution following up on the World Summit for Social Development. The text passed 176 to 3. Washington said it would no longer reaffirm the 2030 Agenda, rejecting the right to development and calling the process an endless cycle of resolutions, conferences and reports. Uruguay, speaking for the group, regretted that the proposal had been forced to a vote.
The United States also brought to a vote assistance to refugees, returnees and displaced persons in Africa, which passed 177 to 1, with 1 abstention. Mali asked from the floor who had called the vote. The United States said it remains Africa’s largest humanitarian donor but rejected the text’s references to the Global Compact on Refugees.
A third US-called vote was on a procedural text that sets up talks on a Palermo Convention protocol on crimes that affect the environment. It passed 152 to 8, with 18 abstentions. The United States cited a UN Office on Drugs and Crime estimate of $300,000 a week for negotiating sessions during the UN’s liquidity crisis. Brazil regretted that even a procedural decision could not be adopted by consensus.
Israel called votes on two texts. A resolution on Palestinian self-determination passed 162 to 8, with 8 abstentions. Egypt, speaking for the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, said the text was only a technical update, questioning the necessity of a vote. Israel, on the other hand, called it another example of double standards. A resolution concerning following up on the 2001 Durban Declaration on racism passed 122 to 16, with 42 abstentions. Israel and the UK framed their lack of support for Durban on antisemitism at the 2001 conference. The US issued a broader condemnation of the concepts behind Durban, framing it as a program designed to “to construct an exaggerated and remarkably one-sided story of the past as a foundation for the assertion of power in the present,” aimed at the reversal of the power structure, the creation of a false historical narrative that blames everything on the West, and the establishment of “a two-tiered system of citizenship, of justice, of law.” Unlike the other four texts, this one also split Western states: France voted no, and the Netherlands and the United Kingdom abstained.
The United States did not take part in negotiations on Mexico’s drug resolution, which passed 151 to 1. It joined consensus on the resolution on corruption, but called that text an exhaustive wish list better handled in Vienna.
Only three texts passed without a vote: on universal self-determination, human rights treaty bodies and corruption. The United States repeatedly objected to language on gender and the Sustainable Development Goals, and Argentina joined some of those objections. Together, this meeting points to a trend that more texts that once passed by consensus will go to recorded votes in the committee.